58 CHARLOTTE Street
St. Augustine, FL 32084
MLS# 1217825
Status:
Closed
Property DescriptionLocated in the high traffic pedestrian area of the nation's oldest city, the property is well-suited for a variety of commercial applications and was previously operated as a Restaurant & Bar.
Sitting on a .21 Acre lot, with a 3,927 SqFt 2 Story Building. this reconstructed Spanish Colonial building had a full remodel in 2003. Entering off Charlotte Street through a private courtyard with gardens and seating, it is a step back in time as you walk through the first floor dining rooms with fireplaces. The second floor, which was originally a residence is currently used as an extra dining room for larger parties, totaling room for approximately 150 seats (90 Seats Paid). The Upgrades to this building are extensive with a new roof in 2015 and 4 new AC Units in 2016.
Parcel Number: 1968800000
Water Body Access YN: No
Waterfront YN: No
Directions: King St. to Charlotte St. N on Charlotte St. between Treasury St. and Hypolita St.
Public Remarks: Located in the high traffic pedestrian area of the nation's oldest city, the property is well-suited for a variety of commercial applications and was previously operated as a Restaurant & Bar.
Sitting on a .21 Acre lot, with a 3,927 SqFt 2 Story Building. this reconstructed Spanish Colonial building had a full remodel in 2003. Entering off Charlotte Street through a private courtyard with gardens and seating, it is a step back in time as you walk through the first floor dining rooms with fireplaces. The second floor, which was originally a residence is currently used as an extra dining room for larger parties, totaling room for approximately 150 seats (90 Seats Paid). The Upgrades to this building are extensive with a new roof in 2015 and 4 new AC Units in 2016.
Building Area Total: 3927
Stories Total: 2
Building Area Source: Appraiser
List Price/SqFt: 891.27
Sold Price/SqFt: 888.72
Year Built: 1967
Commercial: 1
Hotel/Motel: 1
Public Historical Remarks 1: Road Surface: Asphalt Road, Lot Location-Downtown: Y, Approx. Total SqFt: 3927.00, Number of Units: 1 - 4 Units
Public Historical Remarks 2: Number of Buildings: 1 Building, Ceiling Height: 8' - 10' Ceilings
Public Historical Remarks 3: Current Zoning: HP-2, Occupant Type: Special Instructions, Call Listing Agent
Current Price: $3,490,000
Sold Price: $3,490,000
Status: Closed
Listing Contract Date: 2023-03-20
Property Sub Type: Mixed Use
Street Number: 58
Street Name: CHARLOTTE
Street Suffix: Street
County: St. Johns
State: FL
Postal Code: 32084
MLS Area Major: 322-Downtown St Augustine
Major Change Timestamp: 2024-06-26T20:53:58Z
Major Change Type: Status Change
Price Change Timestamp: 2024-01-16T19:04:54Z
Purchase Contract Date: 2024-04-01
Close Date: 2024-06-26
Close Price: 3490000
Business Type: Bed & Breakfast
Construction Materials: Concrete; Stucco
Current Use: Commercial; Hotel/Motel; Multi-Family; Office; Retail; Other
Heating: Central; Heat Pump
Lot Features: Historic Area
Parking Features: Attached; Guest; Parking Lot; Other
Contingency Reason: Inspection
The Original Remodel in 2003 by Gaere MacDonald Construction added a second stair case for fire exit off the second floor, a new kitchen w/ 17 +/- Ft vent hood, a walk-in cooler and so much more. This unique property also has a rare and highly coveted private and fully fenced back parking lot that offers not only parking but plenty of room for an additional deck or patio for more seating potential, The charm of the style and workmanship is evident from the moment you walk in. The HP2 Zoning does allow for Nightly Rentals, Restaurants, Lounges/Taverns, Retail, Offices, Residential and so much more.
Listing Office: GREAT EXPECTATIONS REALTY
Last Updated: February - 22 - 2025
Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed.
Survey on File 
Building Sketch from Previous Appraisal 
